Best DEX: Uniswap, SushiSwap, PancakeSwap?

Uniswap holds the title as the largest DEX overall, while PancakeSwap reigns as the most favored DEX within the Binance blockchain ecosystem. Notably, SushiSwap extends its reach across more than 20 blockchains.

But which one suits your needs best? In this piece, we’ll conduct a head-to-head analysis of Uniswap, SushiSwap, and PancakeSwap!

Decentralized exchanges (DEXs) and Automated Market Makers (AMMs) stand as the cornerstones of decentralized finance (DeFi). Within this article, we delve into what sets these three prominent DEXs (Uniswap, SushiSwap, and PancakeSwap) apart and compare their core attributes.  In the quest to determine the best DEX among Uniswap, SushiSwap, and PancakeSwap, it’s crucial to also consider the safety and security of your assets, which is an essential aspect explored in our article on “Is DeFi Wallet Safe?”

Key Points:

• Uniswap stands out as the top DEX, excelling in market cap, TVL, and monthly volume;
• SushiSwap and PancakeSwap introduce significant innovations, establishing unique ecosystems;
• All three protocols are generally perceived as secure and dependable, with a few historical concerns surrounding SushiSwap;
• Swapping fees range from 0.05% to 1%, with users additionally incurring gas fees tied to their chosen blockchain network.

An In-Depth Look at Uniswap: What You Need to Know

Incepted in 2018, Uniswap stands as a prominent decentralized exchange specializing in the swap of ERC-20 tokens within the Ethereum ecosystem. Additionally, it extends its services across other blockchains such as Arbitrum, Optimism, and Polygon.

Uniswap has witnessed several advancements since its inception, now operating on its third iteration, version V3. The platform imposes trading fees ranging from 0.05% to 1%.

Distinctive Features of Uniswap

• Swap Functionality: Uniswap facilitates the buying and selling of crypto assets across diverse blockchains;
• NFT Trading: It consolidates NFTs from various marketplaces, offering a platform for their purchase and sale;
• Liquidity Pools: Users are empowered to participate in existing pools or establish new ones, with the liberty to customize fees and set price boundaries to optimize capital allocation for maximum returns.

Security Measures of Uniswap

• Transparency: The core smart contracts of Uniswap are accessible for public viewing on the Uniswap V3 Github repository;
• Security Assurance: Uniswap conducts thorough internal code reviews and has undergone several security audits by external firms, the latest of which was in March 2021, revealing predominantly minor issues. Additionally, a bug bounty program has been instrumental in addressing critical vulnerabilities.

The Uniswap Token $UNI

• Governance and Utility: Launched in 2020, the $UNI token is an ERC-20 governance token that empowers its holders with voting rights on key platform decisions, including adjustments to the DEX’s fee structure;
• Anti-Migration Strategy: The introduction of $UNI was a strategic move to retain users amidst competition from SushiSwap;
• Tokenomics: With a fixed cap of 1 billion tokens, the complete supply of $UNI is anticipated to be fully distributed by the end of 2024.

A Closer Look at SushiSwap

SushiSwap represents a dynamic evolution in the decentralized finance (DeFi) sector, extending beyond its roots as a UniSwap derivative. This platform is a hub for cryptocurrency enthusiasts, providing access to a diverse range of over 400 tokens across more than twenty distinct blockchains. Its capabilities are not limited to simple trading; SushiSwap offers a suite of financial services including earning opportunities, yield stacking, and options for lending, borrowing, and leveraging assets. A notable aspect of trading on SushiSwap is the standardized trading fee of 0.3%, in addition to the requisite network transaction fees, commonly known as gas fees.

Diverse Functionalities of SushiSwap

• Crypto Asset Exchange: Utilizes an automated market maker system for efficient swapping of digital assets;
• Kashi: A decentralized market for lending, allowing users to engage in both sides of borrowing and lending. It supports the creation of new lending pairs, in addition to existing ones;
• Onsen: A feature that enables users to stake their assets to earn fees and additional rewards;
• Miso: A set of open-source smart contracts facilitating the launch of new projects within the SushiSwap ecosystem;
• Trident: A flexible framework for building customized automated market makers;
• Furo: A tool designed for the scheduled distribution of tokens, incorporating features for vesting and withdrawal.

Security Measures and Community Trust in SushiSwap

SushiSwap’s operations are heavily influenced by its community, with its open-source nature ensuring transparency, as all code is accessible on its Github repository. The platform collaborates with renowned crypto security firms for regular audits and security reviews, with notable examples including Quantstamp, PeckShield, and Certik. While past reviews have been generally positive, it’s important to note that these audits primarily occurred in 2020 and 2021.

A historical incident worth mentioning occurred in September 2020, involving the misappropriation of several million dollars in $SUSHI tokens by an anonymous developer. This event, followed by the return of the funds and community outcry, led to a significant governance change. The community elected nine representatives to hold the keys to a multi-signature wallet, enhancing the security of SushiSwap’s funds.

The Role of the $SUSHI Token

$SUSHI, an ERC-20 token, lies at the heart of SushiSwap’s governance model. Holders of this token have voting rights on the platform’s future development. The token can be acquired on the open market or earned through liquidity provision on the platform. Staking $SUSHI also opens avenues for additional rewards. The token’s supply is capped at 250 million, with the maximum supply expected to be reached by November 2023.

SushiSwap’s commitment to education and growth is evident in its establishment of the SushiSwap Academy. This resource serves as an informative guide for users to deepen their understanding of the protocol and DeFi at large. Additionally, the roadmap for Sushi 2.0 provides insight into the platform’s future direction, highlighting upcoming features and developments.

The Ins and Outs of PancakeSwap

PancakeSwap stands as a prominent decentralized exchange on the BNB Smart Chain, featuring a diverse range of transaction fees including 0.01%, 0.05%, 0.25%, and 1%.

Diverse Offerings of PancakeSwap

The platform facilitates spot trading through an Automated Market Maker system.

• Earn Rewards through Yield Farming: Users can obtain $CAKE tokens as rewards by providing liquidity to various pools;
• Choice of Staking in Syrup Pools: Offers options between flexible and locked staking to earn $CAKE and additional tokens;
• Prediction Market for Profit: Opportunity to gain rewards by accurately forecasting the price movements of $BNB and $CAKE;
• Participate in Lotteries: Opportunity for users to purchase lottery tickets and potentially win prizes;
• Futures Trading with ApolloX Finance: Engage in perpetual futures trading in collaboration with ApolloX Finance, with no KYC requirement;
• Access to New Tokens through Initial Farm Offering (IFO): A pathway to acquire newly launched tokens on the BNB Smart Chain;
• Trading NFTs: A platform for trading a curated selection of NFTs, including PancakeSwap’s own collections, on the Binance Smart Chain.

Security Measures at PancakeSwap

The DEX’s code and smart contracts are accessible on PancakeSwap’s Github, with all contracts verified on BscScan.

Security Audits and Transparency: PancakeSwap’s security protocols have been audited by notable firms like Certik, with reports indicating few non-critical issues. These audits, available on their website, provide a detailed security history from the platform’s inception in 2020 to May 2023.

The $CAKE Token: Versatility and Utility

$CAKE, a multi-chain token available on BEP20 (BNB Smart Chain), ERC-20, and Aptos Mainnet, has a maximum supply limit of 750 million, expected to be reached by 2025. This aligns with the developers’ roadmap to achieve their goals, as outlined in their Litepaper.

Use Cases for $CAKE: The token serves various purposes, including governance voting, NFT minting, and lottery participation. It can be earned through activities like yield farming and participating in Syrup Pools.

Key Metrics for Uniswap, SushiSwap, and PancakeSwap

Platform	Description	Key Features	Security	Token
Uniswap	Decentralized exchange for ERC-20 Tokens on Ethereum, Arbitrum, Optimism, and Polygon blockchains.	Swap, Trade NFTs, Liquidity pools.	Public core contracts, security audits, code reviews, bug bounty program.	$UNI: Governance token (Max supply: 1B)
SushiSwap	Fork of Uniswap with support for 400+ tokens on 20+ blockchains. Offers lending, borrowing, and leverage.	Asset Swapping, Kashi, Onsen, Miso, Trident, Furo.	Open-source, community-driven, security audits, reviews.	$SUSHI: ERC-20 governance token (Max supply: 250M)
PancakeSwap	Largest DEX on BNB Smart Chain with varying fee tiers.	Spot trading, Yield farming, Syrup Pools, Prediction market, Lottery, Perpetual futures, IFO, NFT trading.	Public code, security audits, contracts verified on BscScan.	$CAKE: BEP20, ERC-20, and Aptos token (Max supply: 750M)

In our analysis of cryptocurrency fundamentals, we examine crucial indicators such as market capitalization, total value locked (TVL) in USD, monthly trading volume in USD, and the performance of token prices for three prominent decentralized exchanges (DEXs) – Uniswap, SushiSwap, and PancakeSwap.

Market Capitalization Overview

As of early May 2023, the market capitalizations of these DEXs are as follows:

• Uniswap: $3.97 billion;
• SushiSwap: $193 million;
• PancakeSwap: $503 million.

Total Value Locked (TVL) Insights

TVL is a vital metric in decentralized finance (DeFi), reflecting the total assets deposited in these platforms. It’s a key indicator of a platform’s overall worth and user trust.

The past year’s trends show a significant contraction in TVL across all three platforms – a decrease from approximately $15 billion to just below $7 billion. Notably, this downtrend reversed somewhat in January 2023.

SushiSwap experienced the most substantial relative decline among the three. Uniswap has consistently led in terms of TVL, while PancakeSwap didn’t maintain its early-year gains.

Monthly Trading Volume Analysis

Monthly trading volumes offer insights into the user engagement and overall health of a DEX.

Over the last year, the combined monthly trading volume of these three DEXs peaked at nearly $99 billion in March 2023, exceeding their previous high in May 2022. However, this momentum declined in April.

Uniswap consistently recorded the highest trading volume, whereas SushiSwap has seen a resurgence since the year’s start.

Token Price Performance Trends

The first two months of the year saw a steady increase in the prices of tokens from these DEXs. This uptrend was followed by a decline until mid-March, then a period of stabilization, and a sharp drop towards the end of April. The price movements appear to correlate significantly with broader market trends, as indicated by comparisons with Wrapped Bitcoin (WBTC) trends.

Conclusion 

In essence, all three platforms excel as decentralized exchanges. Uniswap, being one of the pioneering DEXs, boasts the largest market share and a high level of trust within Ethereum-based blockchain communities. It potentially offers the lowest fees and presents a user-friendly interface for a seamless experience. On the downside, Uniswap primarily offers basic functions like AMM-based swapping and liquidity pool farming. SushiSwap and PancakeSwap, on the other hand, showcase remarkable innovation by providing a wide array of diverse features.  PancakeSwap has emerged as the leading DEX on Binance Smart Chain, while SushiSwap is a versatile multi-chain solution serving Ethereum-based blockchains and other networks like BSC and Fantom.

So, which of these three DEXs suits you best? Your choice largely hinges on the features you intend to utilize and the blockchains you wish to engage in token trading. It’s essential to conduct your own research, considering variables like functionality and fees, which can evolve over time, before making your decision.

FAQ